maybe in linux vlc does menus fine but in windows it's laggy as all for me, and others I know have the same problem. I'm looking for something other than vlc. I have the latest version of vlc, and doing the encoded files as dvd file structures doesn't help. Regardless, this doesn't explain why Nero Showtime can handle the menus just fine and vlc lags so badly. The lag I'm talking about is that you click the item on the DVD menu, and vlc takes a year and a half to get to the next item, again, whereas Showtime doesn't skip a bit(when it doesn't crash). Honestly I don't like showtime, there's no way to enable subtitles by default, it doesn't recognize many commonly used formats, and most of all, it isn't free, so the people I'm working with to make the dvds can't use it(legally). Also to clarify, this is the menus, the overall playback in VLC is great, I need something specifically to test the menus that responds reasonably.